Election 2026: What We Got, What It Means, and What We Do Next: Gonna Wash that Man Right Outta Our Hair

If there was hope, it must lie in the proles, because only there, in those swarming disregarded masses, eighty-five percent of the population of Oceania, could the force to destroy the Party ever be generated. The Party could not be overthrown from within. Its enemies, if it had any enemies, had no way of coming together or even of identifying one another. Even if the legendary Brotherhood existed, as just possibly it might, it was inconceivable that its members could ever assemble in larger numbers than twos and threes. Rebellion meant a look in the eyes, an inflection of the voice; at the most, an occasional whispered word. But the proles, if only they could somehow become conscious of their own strength, would have no need to conspire. They need only to rise up and shake themselves like a horse shaking off flies. If they chose they could blow the Party to pieces tomorrow morning. Surely sooner or later it must occur to them to do it. George Orwell, 1984

Warning: My humor is appropriate here only for adults.

Friends, the unthinkable has happened. I knew we could expect a couple victories here and there, but the polls, once again, were wildly off the mark. I suspect this happens particularly when pollsters fear so much predicting the wrong outcome that they simply assign uniform probability. That is, if two candidates are running, the worst case scenario for prediction is exactly 50%/50%. One can create all the clickbait in the universe, but claiming that spread means there is nothing to say. Perhaps they’re conservative in their estimates for good reason, but we’ve had ample reason to believe otherwise.

On Tuesday my husband and I watched the election coverage well into the night. It really is difficult to express the happy surrealism I experienced as race after impossible race falling to the Democrats, but then again, you probably agree. The vindication is staggering.

We have work ahead of us, but I thought I would jot down my thoughts on what happened last week, along with what I think it means and what our next steps should be. It’s simple to explain–we experienced what appears to be a seismic shift in the political landscape, but we kid ourselves if we take it to mean victory in all ways we could interpret it. To strike the head of the nail, we are sending a very diverse slate of candidates into the seats of power at the local, state, and federal levels. Republicans lost districts and states where they’ve held advantages for decades.

I list these in greater detail below, but my conclusion, if you’re in a hurry is this: do NOT believe that the American electorate now favors diversity. This was a win not for diverse candidates but against a crime syndicate of Biblical proportions that has become the Republican party. That is, racists who voted for Trump but voted for Democrats in this election aren’t magically not racist anymore–racism gives way when you can no longer pay for groceries. Hate doesn’t fill your gas tank. Islamophobia doesn’t pay for your kids’ Christmas presents. Cruelty doesn’t feed your kids. It’s about priorities.

I’ll explain in greater detail below, and if you read until the end, you get a satirical but NOT satire Halloween treat from your shifty-eyed drunken FBI director and a U.S. Senator’s send-up of Leslie Jordan.

What We Got!

These images give you an idea of the shifting sands, lifted from Wikipedia:

U.S. House

U.S. Senate

Guberatorial

Deep in the Heart of Texas

My home state of Texas not only elected James Talarico to the United States Senate (breaking a 23-year-long streak of GOP ownership of those seats), and Gina Hinojosa was elected governor, the first Latina to hold the mansion. Greg Abbott was bounced out of office after decades of delivering for the wealthy and wrecking the education system, and–wait for it–Talarico defeated Trump’s lunatic fringe pick of fraudster, fabulist, and philandering Ken Paxton by double digits! Within 24 hours, we knew that Democrats won every statewide race in my old stomping grounds. We took back the Texas Board of Education! I’m utterly shocked and elated, even as I write this. Take a gander at the Senator-elect, a bright, young, energetic man with a mission. He was raised by a single parent, as was I for much of my childhood.

I believed Talarico could win, but Gina Hinojosa’s win against long-standing (sitting; okay, that was low brow.) Greg Abbott surprised the living holy hell out of me. Texans truly have had enough of the lies and nonsense.

In 2025, Trump directed his toady Governor Abbott and the GOP scumbags in the state legislature to redraw the Texas districts to eliminate five seats occupied by black Democrats. Trump spake, and the sleazy Abbott barked, rolled over, and salivated as he delivered those seats unto his new god. In this election, Republicans lost ALL five of those, despite their new lines making it possible to ride Trump’s double-digit victories in 2024. I told my husband many months ago that the GOP would lose where they didn’t think it was possible. And I was correct. In fact, they lost almost every single district they tried to steal, and it leads to one inescapable conclusion: you cannot disenfranchise black Americans without a heavily mobilized response by said blacks and their allies, and you should fire your fucktard data analysts who did the redrawing. (Well, they belong in prison as far as I’m concerned.) The problem with such a program in a nation in which demographics and priorities shift, and in which some people actually have a community that has their backs, the predictive value of 2024 was worthless.

One can rail about trans and men in girls’ sports and Mexican rapists and Islamic terrorists all day long, but if you rob people of their money, their mobility, and their dignity, they don’t give a shit about whatever (misguided) principles they hold. I think this is a two-way story we’ll examine below.

Southwest-Side Story

The story erupted across the Southwest–my do nothing representative Juan Ciscomani suffered a humiliating defeat, crushed under 52.9% to his much smaller 44.9%. He, like the leprechaun Mike Johnson, insisted as the ship sank that he was the better candidate with a proven track record. I’m still waiting to hear it. Crickets. I would award him MOST INEFFECTIVE SWING STATE REPUBLICAN LIFETIME ACHIEVEMENT AWARD. I’ll bear my old age and inappropriate commentary: Mendoza has more “man” in her little finger than does the cheesy grin factory standing next to his spraypainted idol.

DJT: Who am I? I love my lil’ mexicans.
JC: I’m next to a rapist, but I love the money
.
LC: I wanna die. Thank God for Phenergan.

In Arizona, our governor Katie Hobbs successfully defended the governor’s mansion against Trump’s handpicked Andy Biggs. Despite a meager margin in the election in 2022 pitting her against Fabulista Dominata Kari Lake–the most delusional and ridiculous party candidate in all my life–Hobbs scored a victory in the double digits against Trump-picked Andy Biggs. I guess people followed his political signs’ advice: Don’t forget to vote Biggs! Honestly, I can’t get enough of Kari Lake, even if she’s not the story of the hour. I hear she’s now Empress of Penguins, Mother Superior to Burgess Meredith, Pharoah of Waxen Mummies, Second Uncle to Paul the Apostle, and Emissary to the Dark Side of the Moon. She won all those things! ALL OF THEM! I could riff all day.

Front-seat lunacy of the next Nobel prize winner in Everything! Kari Lake

Instead, look at Governor Hobbs, the picture of decency, kindness, and stellar eyes!

Deb Haaland was the first female Native American to be elected governor in this nation’s history, and it is New Mexico that did the deed–500 years after losing their continent to the white satan, they can finally claim a momentous victory. Their communities are the stuff of legends, casting off centuries of cruel oppression from the colonial overlords. Few peoples can speak so clearly to the ravages of authoritarianism and its many accompanying pustules–racism, greed, psychopathy, and cynicism. The Palestinians come to mind, or peasants under the iron boot of Stalin, or the slaves held here in America, or Indians under British rule, or victims of the Holocaust, or Africans under apartheid. So maybe there aren’t so few.

Southeasterly Winds

The Democrats scored Lady Belle Lindsay Graham’s seat, denying her politically inexperienced sister a full term. Graham himself was just a tragedy–in 2015, he opined that Trump was a poison pill for the GOP, and supporting him would lead to the party’s ruin. He was right, but he chose to be wrong–ten years later, he golfed with him, parroted him, and oozed himself into arguing absurdities that indicated senility. Graham’s legacy will only be saccharine obeisance to the most dangerous and obviously corrupt man in the world. See her bare them vicious fangs and claws–you go girl! His epitaph should read, “a gal willing to go all the way with Trump”.

Instead, we get the picture of sanity, compassion, and intelligence in the pediatrician Doctor Annie Andrews. The ship might not sink with her helping to guide it.

Lindsey Graham hopefully can see this from hell–a woman replaced him, twice.

I will call it–I believe Mississippi has elected Scott Colom to the U.S. Senate, and that would be the first African American governor since Reconstruction. As readers of this blog might recall, Reconstruction was the brief period following the Civil War in which African Americans ascended into leadership positions thanks to the National Guard protecting the ballot box. After the North-South Compact of 1877, the troops abandoned their oversight, and decades of Jim Crow ensued. Even today, the fight continues against racism so prevalent that it hides in plain sight. Colom gives me hope, and it’s funny that his competition personally denied him a seat on the federal bench. Payback’s a bitch, Marie Pick-a-Different-Protein Antoinette.

In Georgia, voters reelected Jon Ossoff–not that anyone is surprised. He’s a doll to behold, and his temperament and bearing are presidential. The big surprise in Georgia’s returns is the election of Keisha Lance Bottoms, the state and country’s first black woman governor. Stacey Abrams did us proud by paving the way!

Presidential composure
Another black woman in Georgia ready to give Trump and the GOP the what-for

North-by-Northeast

The story is similar as we hop about the nation. Maine booted Senator Susan Collins–after six terms of handwringing, cringy anguish as she demonstrated no insight, backbone, or commonsense–to the curb. They replaced her with a fifth generator logger Troy Jackson. He’s blue collar, and frankly just perfect. She claimed in one of their debates that–wait for it–it is inappropriate to ask a nominee to the federal bench about hypothetical decisions in future cases. I don’t know what planet she’s on. Troy Jackson, yes, was pro-life until 2013. But he can admit he was wrong. She can’t. The principle of not asking a future justice how he might rule makes little sense in the context of an issue with millions of lives at stake. Then again, Kavanaugh was credibly accused of rape, and that wasn’t a problem for Collins, either. Well, she’s down and out–cue Bessie Smith.

In a fever of change, we had the first openly gay man to win a Senate seat–and it happened right there in New Hampshire. My heart swells with pride, and I remember my wedding day back in 2014. Here is Senator-elect and his husband on their own beautiful day.

Westward

Nevada elected Aaron Ford, the first African American governor west of the Mississippi River, per NPR.

Aside from the astonishing success in Texas, I would point to three more races of colossal import. First, I cannot overstate the importance of megachurch Methodist pastor Adam Hamilton’s victory in the race for U.S. Senate in Kansas. A Democrat hasn’t held that seat since 1932. It also looks favorable for a victory in the governor’s race in said state. See his interview on The Bulwark. He is decent, thoughtful, intelligent, and ready to do good after the manner of the Savior in which he places his faith. Jesus preached many things that most Christians ignore, and the path can be challenging for greedy cynics who remain certain of satan’s power but wouldn’t help an old lady cross the street. I would argue that they are not Christians in any sense of the word.

Michigan elected the first Muslim American to the U.S. Senate. Abdul El-Sayed is an epidemiologist who decided politics was a better way to lobby for change.

There are many more firsts in this election. Listen to PBS for more on that.

What It Means and What We Do Next

What This Doesn’t Mean

I’m guilty of misdirection, and I admit it. Don’t get me wrong. I’m thrilled with the shifting sands. I believe in DEI. I wept when Hinojosa’s victory was announced. I wept for Deb Haaland’s victory. I wept for Keisha Lance-Bottoms and the Stacey Abrams and the Rosa Parks and every woman of color who ever refused to accept the paltry role and power dealt by a white privilege white grievance establishment. I need only remember my childhood. There still was the colored school, the colored park, the colored pool, and the part of town they were allowed to have. This was years after integration had started, but the tokens of racism and hate remained all around us. You’ve read this far, and I applaud you. I wanted to list those beautiful results to make it clear that I’m not just spouting my opinion here without the context of what we’ve accomplished. I’ll drive the point hard from that.

The diversity is nice to have, as the more firsts of these kind, the easier the future will be for everyone. But I would caution my brethren not to believe that this is self-evident. Many if not most won’t understand it. But if you’re reading this, I believe you can understand it. You’re not dirty, wrong-headed, or behind the times in agreeing with me on this. I’ll state it as clearly as possible–this isn’t a victory for diversity.

Say it again with me, aloud if you can–this is NOT a victory for diversity.

What It Really Means

A massive realignment of political preference has occurred independently of the rage ancient white dinosaurs carry that anyone anywhere is ever an anything. That is to say, when push comes to shove, fears about diversity die. Big girl blouse Ciscomani’s constant parade of ‘men in women’s sports’ critiques of Mendoza were a perfect example. The lesbian veteran beat the pious little prick by double digits–Tucsonians don’t give two fucks about sexual orientation when it comes to gigantic bills, fewer jobs, and less pay. Economic concerns, corruption, tech sector overreach, and illegal and unjust war probably play the biggest roles, and the three are not orthogonal to one another.

Before examining these a little, I want it to sink in–this doesn’t mean the electorate is ready for a gay president. It doesn’t mean a Muslim can be president. I say these things as a gay man. I want someone with the spirit of Pete Buttigieg to be president–he was much like Biden in that regard. I think El-Sayed has a long and prosperous future in politics. Both are young(-ish) men, so the White House isn’t off-limits forever to them. But we cannot miscalculate this–Americans want their problems solved, and they don’t care who solves them. They want corruption to end. But the adversarial blowback will be massive. Psychopathic Christian nationalists making up the GOP remain perhaps the greatest threat to this nation, and the greedy tech billionaires–careless at best and devilish at worst–will finance every effort on their part to reassert control. The people are a threat to them, and they know it. This was true when I worked for big tech, and it’s still true now.

I will go on record here, and I’d much rather be wrong about this–the next candidate we run for president must be straight, white, male, and (preferably Protestant) Christian. There are plenty of good guy choices, and they will fight for me and my rights, as well as you and yours. They will protect Muslim communities. They will stop the war in Iran. They will stop the aid to a military power bent on genocide in Gaza. They will stop playing with Putin like he’s some sort of real leader. I hate this–it dirties my fingers as I type it. It sounds cruel, and perhaps it is, but it’s medicine we progressives must swallow. I voted for Hillary and Kamala, and I have contributed money in every cycle. Those two women were more qualified than almost any other candidates of my lifetime. Clinton, Carter, Biden, and Gore were all such choices. Obama-2012 too, but not Obama-2008. The others had all either been VP, a governor, Secretary of State, or First Lady. My major concern with Obama was that he was too young, and a woman would have been easier to elect than a person of color. We won in any case, but, as I’ve argued here, it wasn’t because Obama was black–it was because the Republicans had managed to wreck our international standing, our economy, and, most seriously, the survivability within multiple countries. Perhaps even worse than that, they consolidated executive power with a defunct legal theory, and we’re still under that spell.

We who care about DEI and believe in it must know the difference between a surrogate who also cares and will respond to our pressure, but doesn’t rankle the fringes. If lifelong Democrats switched to Trump because Obama was black, it’s a loss. Those were people we could have reached. Don’t get me wrong–I bawled my eyes out when Pennsylvania was called for Obama in 2008, and that was the clincher. I believed everything in the world had changed. He would spearhead reform to wrest power away from racists, warmongers, and a political ecosystem which would tell him and all other people of color to await a turn which would never come.

Well, the story was different. Obama governed old school, moving on from the horrendous war crimes of Bush W and Cheney. He went on to committing a few of his own, but we got the Affordable Care Act in exchange. But Obama would never sit right with people who feared not having the master’s whip. Yes, it’s fucking repugnant to me even as I write it. But racism dies slowly, demanding immersion, community, and love. It’s a fever. It’s a disease. It didn’t disappear–it just scurried back to the shadows where it could fester, planning its next adversarial move. Two terms later, we have Trump’s birther nonsense and the DNC’s complacency with respect to Bernie and Hillary leading to an unbelievable victory for evil that plunged us into a decade of madness. And for ten years, we’ve had to listen to the orange fathead. And people have died because of it. Iran could be worse even than Iraq if we don’t stop it.

I know this is hard to hear. I texted Noam Chomsky about Obama’s reelection victory in 2012, and how much I though good things would come. His response was something I understand even more now, along the lines of “civil society and its institutions are weakening,” meaning that Americans were more isolated, more atomized, more radicalized than before. Obama likely couldn’t heal this, no matter the good he did as president. I would argue that like Carter, Obama and his beautiful wife Michelle will go on to be great elder statespersons.

Running a candidate with added diversity would be fine in a political climate in which the two parties function as intended. But the current Republican party is the most dangerous organization in human history, with far greater reach than the Nazis, the Stalinists, and the age-old slave-trading British Empire. It’s more dangerous than the colonial forces who eradicated the natives here. Why? Because they accelerate the existential crises in ways the others couldn’t dream. Misery flowed freely from all those evils, but the GOP has both the reach and malevolent intent. The countdown is running down, and soon enough, decent survival in this world will be impossible. We CANNOT permit them back into power. We CANNOT let them off the hook. We CANNOT permit them to destroy us.

It’s Still the Economy, Stupid

Bernie Sanders recently argued that the inequality of household wealth in America has never been more unfair than it is right now. Elon Musk himself holds more wealth than the bottom 50% combined. People are struggling, even as massive data centers move into their communities to leech water and power away from them. The business lobby salivate themselves into hypovolemic shock when the fabulists and fraudsters in tech leadership promise to automate all workers away. Fake AI is ubiquitous, and it isn’t helping us. Boomers hate it. My generation hates it. Kids are angry that they can’t get jobs. The economy is terrible, we’re in an illegal terrorist war murdering people without any real justification, and each institution in the federal government is headed by the most corrupt people to hold those positions. I’m looking at you, Chief Justice John Roberts, Speaker Mike Johnson, Former Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, and, of course, the orange gas-bag playing with pens and markers during life-and-death cabinet meetings. He loves his ballrooms, monuments, and slathering his fetid name all over everything. “MINE, MINE, MINE.” Jesus, someone lock him in memory care. Say his name three times, and you’ll smell the rot of his edamatous blubbery ass.

Source: Wikipedia

Speaking of terrible pieces of shit, Elon Musk is, by all accounts, one of the most hated people entrenched in American politics. With a favorability of maybe 38%, he barrels forward with $446M dumped into Paxton’s unsuccessful run against Talarico. He bribed voters for 2024. He has done perhaps irreparable harm to the essential bureaucracy of the federal government. His business dealings, narcipathic threats to innocents, and rageful, Nazi tantrums leave many ordinary folk nauseated. The reckoning is now coming: Hinojosa intends to reexamine his dealings in the once-was-a-Republic state. No matter the outcome, Musk and his wretched determination to install dupes, crooks, and flimflams has failed. He is a failure. Voters want accountability on these people. Vivek Ramaswamy, another repugnant tech billionaire, lost his bid for governor of Ohio. These faux techies are part of the looming problem presented by runaway griftopia (Zitron’s word).

My prescription: Pass Medicare for All, Green New Deal, and Education Reform on day one.

People Are Sick to Death of the Kleptocracy

Corruption deserved a shout-out. His is the most corrupt administration in history–he pockets literally billions of dollars each year by insider trading. His unilateral economic policies have hurt the working and poor while he and his billionaire buddies make more money. It will take a mountain of lawyers to dig through every scam, theft, and bribe. I don’t possess the strength to go through it now, but if you’re reading this, it’s already something you’re aware of.

Trump is the ultimate kleptomancer, capable of summoning the greatest forces for greed known in this realm and maybe the next. His schemes are forward-facing and unapologetic. He sells cryptocurrency, access, and ridiculous trinket merchandise like Trump passports, Trump bibles, Trump commemorative coins, and Trump Trump Trump fuck make it stop!!!

Congress has refused to act, with Mike Johnson dismissing the lower body every single time a vote comes up to do the right thing. The Senate is little better, towing a line in protecting Trump. Democrats are questioning officials, but it’s mainly a for-show ability without the gavel. Well, that ends in January. Lawyer up, bitches.

My recommendation: Impeach on day one. With two years to his term, he represents the most terrible threat to American and the world in all our long, long history. He’s willing to attack other countries unilaterally. He energizes a psychotic base who will play Halloween-complete-with-masks shoot’em-ups with brown and even a few white people. He sells government secrets to the likes of Jensen Huang, a man so stupid that he falls prey to a Chinese spy who “do him good in bed.” He stops investigations into poison in our food. He’s gutted the CDC, so a pandemic could cripple us permanently. The do-nothing-bumfuck GOP senators in Congress see that John Cornyn, the more respectable Texas US senator couldn’t prevail, and his replacement lost by double digits. We bounced out the governor. In fucking Texas! Ted Cruz isn’t well-liked at all, and he admitted that things need to change; way to go, sir! You could fly to Cancun and never come back! Susan Collins is out on her equivocating perseverating ass. Lady Belle’s seat will now have a Democrat, a pediatrician who actually cares about human beings. The GOP stronghold isn’t safe from the roar of the American people. I think they’ll vote to convict and remove Trump–it may be the only way for them to survive this politically.

I also believe we should impeach John Roberts, Clarence Thomas, and Samuel Alito. Their grifts are the stuff of legends, and we can replace them when we have the White House in the next term.

The Virtual Trojan Horse of Tech

The truth is after 20 years of working at tech, I can say that most were decent people. Almost none were willing to put their opinions on the record (in fact, I think I’m only one of two or three people I know after connecting with a few thousand), but most just wanted to do what was right. But when they go bad, they really go bad. My manager over at Microsoft Azure was (and is since the company still pays him) one of the nuttiest, most narcissistic, most infantile bosses I’ve ever had. He forced personality tests on his people so he could deride them. He preyed on my health struggles, ridiculed my sexual orientation, and actively sabotaged my work. I had been hired to train the team on data science, and instead, he commanded his other reports to spy on me and report any instances in which I talked to them. It was the stuff of satire. He was bloated, arrogant, and a bellow of laughter at his own jokes–the only joke was him. I had a manager at Uber who threatened me even with physical violence in his dry-drunk delirium. He was a broken person, but undeserving of any team below him. Uber did push him out eventually. Both of those examples I reported to HR. The Microsoft manager could point to nothing since my team on the Ads stack stood by me and were glad to have me. I had one other bad manager earlier on, but of the dozen or so that I’ve had, most were average to exceptional. The bell curve was there, though the left tail was fatter than the right. My experience is anecdotal, but I’m talking about elite tech, not some bumfuck tiny firm in the heartland.

One zombie hemorrhoid of a problem was that management pushed newer tech to attract more from elite tech research. If a person researched a very narrow inequality tied to some set of incalculable conditions, management would require people to try it. Deep learning was an excellent example of this. I hear tell from my old buddies that LLMs have been the ultimate manifestation–a messianic boon to do-nothing execs who brag to their golf buddies about the chatbots reading and replying to emails. These are people who are paid more money than most can imagine. A six-figure salary is huge for most Americans. Try seven or even eight.

The future of tech is grim. Ed Zitron discusses this frequently in his podcasts, articles, and media appearances. The major promotors of generative AI and its various grift-spawn are headed for the bank-variant of the gallows, even as they persuade uncritical tech media of their everyone-should-know-this brilliance. OpenAI and Anthropic will continue to flounder as the true cost of running their tools becomes known. Trillion dollar illusionists of the Theranos ilk are all they are. They mesmerize people with cheap magic tricks, generate buzz and funding, then continue to consult ketamine and ambien for the deeper answers. The larger tech firms who held once immovable, unshakable positions in the pantheon are now facing starvation. For ten years, none created any new incredible tech to revolutionize the industry, and the bloat in their valuation was slowing as expected. Instead of searching for a genuine new gizmo to sell, they repackaged an old idea and raped us with it. Copilot appears everywhere. Stars and AI nonsense are options on everything. Literally every block I create in this blog article comes with an option to let AI do it. (Of course, hell will have to manifest as a real thing, freeze over, melt away, and repeat a dozen times before I will ever use it.) It now clogs search engines, generating lies and fat you care nothing about when searching for the true marrow of it. It’s everywhere, and you have to opt out of it to prevent it from copying everything you are into its models to pick your pocket and control your behavior. Do you want to opt out? You can find instructions here.

My recommendation: Start by enforcing existing law and regulations. This means breaking up monopolies, stopping the data center fever dream, and charging the fraudsters with crimes. Regulations are coming, and it’s time to take back our economic destiny.

No More War

War returns, and this time it’s just as ugly, just as immoral, and just as destructive as it always has been. But things are a little different this time. First, Iran is the strongest of the five the defunct thinktank PNAC suggested America destroy and rebuild. Second, there has never been a justification, exit strategy, or strategy of any kind articulated for this war. Third, the closure of Hormuz means everyone’s costs skyrocket. The Iranians don’t need critical infrastructure to build drones. And the more churches, parks, and schools we bomb, the more they will fight for their country.

Since World War II, our own policy analysts studied the results of bombing civilians. Resoundingly, no matter the side, and no matter the reason, you force the remaining civilians to embrace whatever leader they have at the time. Many Germans who weren’t keen on Hitler or Nazism embraced it later when we firebombed Dresden. When the Nazis bombed London, it would have been preposterous to think they would say to themselves, “Gee, that Bloody Hitler is our kinda man.” The Japanese saw Tokyo, Hiroshima, and Nagasaki, and it was a challenge to think of Americans in a favorable light. The point is bombing civilians NEVER results in a strategic win. It doesn’t matter what side you’re on. For whatever reason, this is a lesson we haven’t learned. Even if there had been some genuine rationale for bragging about destroying a whole civilization, it doesn’t matter. The fact is this–though we’re pretty certain they never planned to build a nuke, we’ve given the Iranians ample reason to do so. We’ll bomb them when we want, and the mother fucker who did it gets to ooze his orange diarrhea all over the White House for the next two years. There is no justice in a world in which a mass murderer, rapist, pedophile faces no real consequences, while we kill leaders of other countries for no reason at all. Good job, SCOTUS on your wizardry–you transmuted a plumb into an orange turd.

When I was a kid, I had many friends from the World War Two generation. They knew Nazis were evil. Even the racist folks I knew. They believed in a better way. Now, people return to hate with hyenas like Musk, Bezos, and Zuck prodding them along. Dumbass Joe Rogan listeners who hate when their wives laugh at their tiny pricks. Change the channel, please.

We owe it to our victims to make restitution. Murder is murder, and one cannot simply call it “war” to justify it. People die everyday in this world for completely avoidable excuses. That must end, and it doesn’t matter who’s in power–hold their fucking feet to the Soldering iron.

My recommendation: Hand over our war criminals for trials under the UN Charter. Impeach and remove, and reassert sane policy.

Concluding Treat

As promised, here’s a treat you have to see to believe. Again, adult humor here, kiddos! This was a real exchange between the lunatic FBI head and a Trump-loving senator.

The Conservative Nanny State : A Book Review Part Six : Small Business, Taxation, Public versus Private, and Roots of Mythology

In our concluding article analyzing Dean Baker’s The Conservative Nanny State, we touch on the role of the archetypal small business, taxation, and the persistent, seemingly immortal debate on private versus public infrastructure, all with respect to the pantheon of the mythology.

Small Business Blight

Baker argues that the small business occupies a unique, critical niche within the mythology : nanny state purveyors sell policy decisions often on the basis of how said policies affect small businesses in aggregate, based on the pervasive perspective that small businesses are a highly desirable feature of the economy.  Analysts across the political spectrum laud small business in editorial after editorial, such as left-leaning Huffington Post and right-leaning Forbes.  It’s so deeply embedded in our framework that to even ask whether small businesses are, in fact, better for the economy remains anathema.  Arguments range from job creation, financial independence, patent creation relative to big businesses, and the like.  Of course, we previously discussed whether patents really do represent innovation, to say nothing of encouraging it.

Before answering either way, Baker lists cases in which nanny state enthusiasts leverage the widely accepted propaganda to argue policy.  For example, Congress very nearly repealed the estate tax in the early years of George W. Bush’s administration, offering up the hapless small farmer as a would-be victim of the vicious “death tax.”  Baker argues reasonably well that the example is mostly nonexistent, owing largely to the zero bracket and the fact that most of the so-called small businesses affected are not genuine small businesses, but rather partnerships designated to be tax shelters, defined by the Congressional Joint Committee on Taxation.  The New York Times remarked in 2001 that the American Farm Bureau was unable to locate any families who lost their farms due to the estate tax.  The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities suggests recently with Donald Trump’s mad push for dissolving the tax that the true effect of repeal is shielding most inherited wealth from any taxation, as much accumulated wealth among those touched by the tax is untaxed income.  A similar argument applies to Trump’s insistence that most taxes, incidentally perhaps the only taxes he’s paid recently, should be lower to encourage economic growth.  Another interesting discussion on this topic is Nicholas Johnson’s article analyzing the actual effects of a 2012 tax break in North Carolina, promoted of course disingenuously as small business support.

In any case, Baker moves on to argue that the job creation precept of small businesses is actually misdirection, echoed later by The Fiscal Times : small businesses destroy perhaps as many jobs as they create, promoting uncertainty and churn in employment.  Further, he observes that tenure at larger firms is longer, benefits are better, and stability is greater.  More recently, a refrain from critics of the Affordable Care Act is the would-be damage to small businesses.  And yet the mandated requirements actually nudge employment quality in small businesses closer to that of larger firms.

The ACA debate hints at a larger argument that regulation inherently hurts businesses, reliably trumpeted by the conservative Heritage Foundation.  Of course, their arguments, promoted by debunked supply-siders, mandate we accept that a job is universally good, irrespective of the quality or pay.  Their predictable argument is that regulations

may be treated as "unnecessary"
if (1) the costs they impose
exceed the benefits they produce,
or (2) even though they produce
benefits that may exceed costs,
they do so in an unnecessarily
costly manner because of an
inefficient method or approach[.]

Their optimization strategy places money first, captured nicely by the following : if I successfully lobby the government to revoke that pesky “regulation” preventing me from lawfully confiscating my neighbor’s cache of groceries, I’ll save money.  Further, it is indeed inefficient for me to simply not have access to my neighbor’s food, as I have to obtain my own food otherwise.  How does this differ?  Multiply this argument into “externalities” such as dumping lead and other toxins into the water supply and relaxing safety regulations in manufacturing, and one begins to appreciate that more than the job is at stake.

Baker argues further that small businesses receive powerful nanny state protections, such as adjusted tax framework, reduced interest loans, lax safety protocols, minimum wage exemptions, and laughably ineffective self-disclosure regulation of environmental violations.  It turns out that the tax framework permits small business owners to deduct all manner of goods and services, perhaps required regardless of whether that person is a business owner (such as an automobile or a computer), costing the taxpayers.  Further, government subsidies for loans to failed small businesses can be staggering, described in Forbes and a few more hysterical right wing libertarian blogs.  That is, we the taxpayer foot the bill for unstable, mostly failed businesses who enjoy nanny state protections against labor, wage, and environmental regulation and means of pocketing breaks.  He correctly observes that citizens requiring TANF benefits to feed their children receive near universal excoriation while failed businesses and illegal deductions rarely enter the discussion, let alone suffer bad press.

Admittedly, small businesses contribute some desirable dynamism to the economy, but the usual question is whether they are an optimal instrument within free market or social experiment framework; if they were, they wouldn’t require such strong protections to succeed.

Taxes, Taxes…

Baker argues rather holistically against the ignorant perspective of nanny state promoters, that taxes are a voluntary donation.  I’ve listened for decades to family and friends bemoaning of the prospect of a single red cent of their hard-earned money finding its way to welfare recipients.  I remarked that the rate of welfare fraud, coupled with the infinitesimal fraction of discretionary spending moving into the hands of these people is virtually zero; money of higher orders of magnitude flows freely into the mass murder machine of the military and, as suggested earlier, giant tax deductions by corporations.  Tax evasion is rampant in the U.S., a partial list of which appears in Wikipedia; Baker cites a study by the IRS reported in the New York Times in 2006 demonstrating an escalation in high-dollar evasion.  It shouldn’t be a surprise that most evasion cases never reach prosecution.  What’s worse, as of 2006 thirty percent of federal taxes remained uncollected, meaning that if the evaders paid their fair share,

tax rates could be reduced
for everyone by twenty-five
percent, and the federal
government would have the
same amount money.

By contrast, if all TANF recipients, as the nanny state supporters like to suggest, got jobs and got off the government dole, we could reduce our tax burden by a whopping 1.4%.  The conservative nanny state mythology appears more and more to be a carnival mirror of stupidity.

More recently, Trump has stumped for lowering the corporate tax rates, arguing as expected that the current burden is overwhelming to American companies.  And yet the assertion, like most parroted by Donald, is patently false, as documented in April by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.  Corporate profits are growing, and the rich are getting richer.  How would reducing a largely unpaid tax burden help working people?  It’s worth remembering the the top individual income tax rate in 1944 was ninety-four percent for earnings above $200,000, or $2.5 million in 2017 dollars.  Innovation, economic growth, and a vibrant technology sector generated by state spending were humming along nicely.

Baker points out that this nanny state gentlemen’s agreement on evasion doesn’t extend to filers requiring the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), discussed by the New York Times; audit rates are readily available by income level from the IRS, documented by USA Today.  The gist is that twenty percent of those filing for the EITC receive requests for additional information, akin to a mini-audit.  By contrast, less that twenty percent of earners with income above $10 million ever receive an audit.

Baker continues with a discussion on internet sales, quite interesting in and of itself; suffice it to say that retail giants such as Amazon had escaped paying sales taxes because of ambiguities in managing purchases across state lines.  The public relations defense against self-disclosure was simply that the administrative burden was too high; this is patently false.  When I worked in Amazon Last Mile Logistics, we routinely handled varying jurisdictions in the company’s deliveries.  The complexity of operating in multiple geographies scales easily, as anyone familiar with the space should know.

Finally, he tackles the curious distinction between stock trading, casino gambling, and ordinary scratch-off and lottery tickets.  The taxation rates are astonishingly regressive, ordinary lottery wins being roughly thirty percent, casino gambling seven percent, and stock trading a brutal 0.003%!

Why is Private Better?

We’ve argued at length in previous posts about state capitalism, the economic system, despite all smoke and mirrors, under which we operate.  A pervasive argument of conservative pundits and nanny state babies is that private corporations can easily outperform public agencies because of waste intrinsic to their structure.  That is to say, without the pressure of profit mandates, shareholder backlash, and market principles, government agencies can profligately expend resources enriching themselves and preserving their positions.  By contrast, private organizations, we’re told, operate more efficiently with minimal largess.

I shouldn’t even have to quote statistics or studies to undermine this absurd notion, as anyone who’s ever worked in corporate America knows this simply isn’t true.  It isn’t to say that customer service, after a fashion, might be better in private agencies, as public agencies are generally quite underfunded, part of a scheme by conservatives to “starve the beast,” a notion to which we’ll return.  But this suggests not that all products and services are more sensibly driven by markets, as the destructive nature of markets is well-understood (and there would be no nanny state if this weren’t the case), rather perhaps customer service itself is better left to private organizations.

Donald Kettl, professor at the University of Maryland, penned an interesting op-ed in Excellence in Government, arguing a dual blame to so-called liberals and conservatives : liberals forgot to work out the details of their big ideas, and conservatives have actively, successfully fought to starve and dismantle the administrative state, an oft-mentioned strategy in connection to the recently fired Steven Bannon.  I’d disagree on some of the terminology, but Kettl correctly argues that the political left in this country ceased to operate among the political elites many decades ago.

Baker’s key arguments are that Social Security and Medicare operate on remarkably low overhead, as marketing and monstrous compensation packages for executives simply don’t exist.  He goes on to sketch an argument we’ve mentioned previously, that health insurance ought to be nationalized for the sake of the population.  As David Swanson so aptly put it, Americans can discover, oddly, that other countries exist, and that they’re leveraging universal health insurance programs, as Physicians for a National Health Program have long advocated.  We need not repeat all the arguments here, but as Noam Chomsky so often describes our current, fragmented joke of a system, it’s

an international scandal.
It’s roughly twice the per
capita costs of comparable
countries, and some of the
worst outcomes, mainly because
it’s privatized, extremely
inefficient, bureaucratized,
lots of bill paying, lots of
officials, tons of money wasted,
healthcare in the hands of
profit-seeking institutions,
which are not health
institutions, of course.

Considering, as we have previously, that virtually all technology which we take for granted originated in the state sector, and that no private agency would underwrite such long term investments, it should be glaringly obvious the role the nanny state plays in generating technology, then handing it off to private interests once it’s become marketable.  The nanny state mythology, astonishingly, convinces even highly educated people that the market somehow spins all of this from whole cloth.

Summary : Why A Nanny State?

In summary, Dean Baker’s book is an awesome read, filled with powerful arguments of which we can only scratch the surface.  He has many more recent works with additional facts and figures worth perusing, but The Conservative Nanny State is a primer for many a discussion on the proper role of government in the economy.

So why does the mythology tickle so many ears?  I grew up hearing so much of the rhetoric, and I’ll admit it seemed reasonable at the time.  With much research, I must confess the answers are quite disturbing.  As Chomsky mentions quite frequently, the rise of the public relations industry under Edward Bernays was a product of the remarkable success of the Department of Information (later the Ministry of Information) in convincing not particularly violent citizenry into warring against their white brethren in World War One.  Walter Lippmann and other premiere intellectuals of the day discovered that the power to “manufacture consent” was the only tool remaining in the toolbox, as violence eventually won’t work in an increasingly democratic setting.  Relegating the rabble, the “meddlesome outsiders” to passive spectatorship in policy and active villainy in war is a monumental achievement, and crucial to this effort is a series of scares, beginning with Wilson’s Red Scare, the propaganda around Cuba’s communist roots of the 1920s mentioned earlier, McCarthyism, and the like.  I can remember my uncle reminiscing about listening to records of Ronald Reagan during elementary and middle school, in which Ronnie explained that universal healthcare is a thing of the communists.  Of course, he neglected to mention that his government positions ensured glorious medical care well into his sad last days of Alzheimer’s dementia; unfortunately, he neglected to offer an appropriate avenue for poor white brethren to secure similar, reasonable old age accommodations, to say nothing of the black and brown.

The gist is that the conservative nanny state mythology is a remarkable feat of propaganda and avarice, designed effectively to persuade poor spectators into stumping for obscenely wealthy men with whom they’ll never associate.  Rush Limbaugh, one of the principal advocates for said state, has argued that income mobility ensures egalitarianism in our system.  Would that his variant of egalitarianism cure his stupidity.

The simplest explanation, as William of Ockham once suggested, might be correct.  Power and money has enabled an overclass to systematically hijack the debate, reframing policy discussions in their own image, just as is suggested in the Powell Memorandum.  As for the book, read it.